Skip to content

Presidential debates don’t hold much weight for voters

October 29, 2012

The three presidential debates have concluded, but voters question how accurate the televised event portrays the candidates. Although public opinion polls and news organizations report a winner of each of the three debates, Elon University students said the extent to which the debates impact voter preference is minimal.

“I personally believe the debates are not a good representation of what their stance on the issue is because they have to give their opinions in a way that is going to appeal to all viewers,” said junior Katie Osborn.

Osborn’s opinion aligns with a near-majority of registered voters, according to a NBC-Wall Street Journal poll. While the poll reports the debates motivated 27 percent of respondents are more likely to support the Republican Candidate Mitt Romney and 24 percent of respondents are more likely to support Barack Obama, 47 percent indicated the debates made no difference.

Based on data collected from CNN/ORC poll. Graph by Melissa Kansky.

A poll conducted by CNN/ORC nearly echoed the results of NBC-Wall Street Journal poll. Of those questioned, 24 percent were more inclined to vote for Obama, 25 percent leaned toward Romney and 50 percent said they were not influenced.

Senior Genevieve D’Cruz identifies with the plurality of individuals whose views were not impacted by the debates. D’Cruz, who watched the first two presidential debates, expressed frustration with the lack of information provided during the political event.

“I wasn’t learning anything from listening to the debate,” she said. “I’m just hearing one candidate bash the other candidate.”

Osborn encouraged voters to turn to governmental websites and review the candidates voting records rather than trusting the debates. Online resources better illuminate the candidates’ values, she said.

Google Trends revealed the 2012 presidential debates have been followed by increases in searches of terms of interest for the two candidates.

“You need to make sure you’re doing the background research on what they voted for in the past and also what their stances are in real life,” Osborn said.

Nevertheless, some students appreciate how the debates reveal the personality of the candidates and allow the candidates’ presentation to influence their voter preference.

Junior Lindsay Glosson, who identifies as an independent, said Romney appealed to her during the first two debates because he addressed her concerns about the last four years, but following the series of debates she is still undecided.

His inability to actually state facts or approach certain areas of the third debate with any form of confidence was a little unnerving – Junior Lindsay Glosson

While she favored Romney following the first two debates, the candidate’s presentation during the third debate diminished her confidence in the Republican challenger.

“His inability to actually state facts or approach certain areas of the third debate with any form of confidence was a little unnerving,” she said.

Although the debates reduced her support for Romney, they have not solidified her vote for Obama either, she said.

The candidate’s conduct during the debates also impacted junior Amanda Lang’s views. Even though public opinion polls identified Obama as the winner of the last two debates, Lang said she sided more with Romney.

Sophomore Brogan Boles also gave weight to the presidential candidates’ behavior and delivery during the debates.

“That was important to me because it showed their leadership qualities and how they would go about leading a country,” Boles said.

No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: